The 2018 S5 has garnered attention as a compelling sports coupe, prompting discussions about its capabilities, particularly when stacked against rivals like the BMW M4. Initial impressions of the S5 often highlight its sophisticated interior and the potential for rapid launches thanks to its Quattro all-wheel-drive system. However, a deeper dive into its performance and handling characteristics reveals a more nuanced picture.
One key point of debate revolves around straight-line speed. While the 2018 S5, with its stated 354 horsepower, might seem like a match for the M4 off the line, especially in less-than-ideal conditions where AWD provides a traction advantage, real-world scenarios and in-gear acceleration tell a different story. Once both cars achieve traction, the M4, boasting a higher trap speed, demonstrates superior acceleration. The performance gap becomes more pronounced as speeds increase, placing the two cars in different leagues when it comes to outright pace.
Handling is another critical area for sports coupes, and here the discussion also favors the M4. The 2018 S5, while offering competent handling, is often described as being heavier and softer compared to the M4. Weight distribution plays a significant role, and the positioning of Audi’s engines further forward in the chassis contributes to a less ideal balance compared to the M4. While features like a sport rear differential can enhance the S5’s agility, the fundamental weight distribution difference impacts its overall nimbleness and responsiveness in demanding handling situations. Track tests and agility assessments would likely underscore these differences, with the M4 generally considered to have the edge in terms of pure handling prowess.
Despite these performance considerations, the interior of the 2018 S5 is consistently praised. Audi has a reputation for crafting refined and aesthetically pleasing cabins, and the S5 is no exception. The quality of materials and the overall design contribute to a premium and comfortable driving environment.
Ultimately, the 2018 S5 presents a compelling package as a sports coupe, particularly for those prioritizing all-weather capability and interior luxury. However, when directly compared to the BMW M4, especially in terms of outright acceleration and handling dynamics, the M4 occupies a higher performance tier. The choice between the two often boils down to individual priorities and driving preferences.
