Stepping up to the 2023 Cadillac XT5 for the first time, the immediate impression is its substantial size. This midsize SUV occupies its space assertively, larger than anticipated, and commands attention in any parking lot. Initially, its dimensions might feel overwhelming, but after spending a day behind the wheel, the XT5’s presence and capabilities begin to resonate.
First Impressions: Size and Styling
My introduction to the 2023 Cadillac XT5 happened at Seattle Tacoma International Airport. Opting for an SUV wasn’t essential for my plans, but an appealing rental offer led me to select this model. Having seen images online, the XT5 appeared stylish, even more so than competing models like the BMW X3. Appearance plays a significant role in my vehicle choices, so I was eager to experience this SUV firsthand.
However, my first in-person encounter with the XT5 was surprising. It was larger than expected, prompting a moment of doubt if the rental agency had assigned the correct vehicle.
2023 Black Cadillac XT5 Front three-quarter view
The sheer presence of the 2023 Xt5 is undeniable. It stands tall, overlooking much of its surroundings and confidently fills parking spaces. Its height is noticeably more imposing than vehicles like the 2020 Porsche Macan.
Despite its imposing size, the XT5 is a well-designed vehicle. The styling is refined without being ostentatious, a trait not always associated with Cadillac. It possesses a certain understated class, making it an SUV one can drive without feeling self-conscious.
While subjective, in my opinion, the 2023 Nissan Rogue edges out the XT5 in terms of pure aesthetics. This is a testament to how competitive the SUV design landscape has become.
2023 black cadillac xt5 side view
The XT5 projects a mature, perhaps even “grandpa” vibe, due in part to the generous use of chrome trim.
However, there’s no mistaking the 2023 XT5 for a generic SUV. It carries distinct Cadillac DNA in its design language.
2023 cadillac xt5 exterior design details
Engine and Driving Performance
The reviewed 2023 Cadillac XT5 was equipped with a 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine, producing 235 horsepower and 258 lb-ft of torque. For an SUV of this size, the engine’s output feels somewhat modest.
2 L four-cylinder engine in the 2023 Cadillac XT5
Reflecting on Cadillac’s heritage, one recalls a time when models boasted massive 7.0-liter V8 engines. While those days are in the past, the comparison highlights a shift in engine philosophy. The 2.0L turbo in the 2023 XT5, while adequate for daily driving, lacks the exhilarating power expected in a luxury vehicle at this price point. It doesn’t deliver the kind of acceleration that evokes excitement; in fact, its performance feels comparable to that of a standard sedan like a 2013 Toyota Camry.
2 L four-cylinder engine in the 2023 Cadillac XT5
It’s interesting to consider how drivers of classic, large Cadillacs from the 1970s might perceive a four-cylinder turbocharged engine in a modern Cadillac. Times have certainly changed, and while efficiency is now prioritized, a segment of drivers still yearns for the robust power of larger engines in luxury SUVs.
Scott driving a 2023 cadillac XT5
Luxurious and Comfortable Interior
Moving past the engine, the interior of the 2023 XT5 is a significant highlight. It’s exceptionally comfortable and well-appointed, a trait also noted in reviews of other recent Cadillac models like the CT4. Cadillac seems to be focusing on interior quality and comfort, and it shows in the XT5.
While opinions may vary, the interior design of the XT5 is generally well-received. It marks a considerable improvement over older Cadillac SUVs. For instance, compared to the 2016 Cadillac SRX, the 2023 XT5 offers a vastly more comfortable and engaging cabin experience.
The dashboard design might be considered somewhat stylized, potentially appearing a bit too assertive for more conservative tastes. However, this bolder styling could be intentional, aiming to attract a broader demographic. It’s unlikely to be a top pick for the traditionally conservative AARP demographic, but it appeals to a modern sensibility.
2023 cadillac xt5 center console and gear selector
The gear selector and center console are ergonomically designed and contribute to the overall premium feel of the interior.
2023 cadillac xt5 backseat
Passenger space in the back is generous, offering ample room for adults. The cabin is remarkably quiet, enhancing the sense of luxury, although the engine noise becomes noticeable during acceleration.
2023 Cadillac XT5 driving POV
Visibility from the driver’s seat is excellent, contributing to a confident driving experience. This is a significant advantage, especially in a vehicle of this size.
2023 cadillac xt5 moonroof
The expansive moonroof further enhances the interior’s spaciousness and lightens the cabin environment.
2023 cadillac xt5 rear cargo area
Cargo space is substantial, easily accommodating the needs of most users. It’s a practical SUV in terms of storage capacity.
2023 cadillac xt5 infotainment screen
A notable drawback is the infotainment display. Its angle and brightness can lead to visibility issues, particularly in sunny conditions due to reflections. However, the inclusion of Apple CarPlay is a welcome feature, though its usability is hampered by the screen’s design.
Ride Comfort and Handling
The 2023 XT5 is not designed for aggressive cornering. Its size and weight mean it’s not as agile as smaller, sportier vehicles. Attempting spirited driving on winding roads will likely feel ungainly.
However, in typical driving scenarios, the XT5 excels in comfort. It smoothly handles various road surfaces, living up to expectations for a 3915 lb SUV. Highway cruising at speed is exceptionally comfortable, feeling stable and serene. The independent suspension with magnetic ride control effectively absorbs road imperfections, making potholed roads less jarring. This SUV is equally suited for long road trips and daily commutes, prioritizing passenger comfort.
2023 cadillac xt5 tires and wheels
The tire and wheel combination (235/65R18) is not sporty but provides adequate grip for safe, everyday driving. They are more than sufficient for preventing loss of control under normal driving conditions.
2023 cadillac xt5 steering wheel
The 2023 Cadillac XT5 is most at home in relaxed, straight-line driving. While it can handle more demanding situations, its strengths lie in providing a comfortable and composed ride during typical commutes and highway journeys.
Fuel Efficiency
The 2.0L engine does offer a benefit in fuel economy, at least in theory. However, real-world MPG can vary significantly based on driving style. During the test drive, which included a more spirited driving style, fuel economy averaged around 18 MPG in the city and 24 MPG on the highway.
2023 cadillac xt5 at the gas station
Fuel consumption can be higher if driven aggressively; more conservative driving should yield better fuel economy figures.
Practicality as a Daily Driver
The 2023 Cadillac XT5 is a highly practical choice for a daily driver. It presents itself as a luxury SUV without being overly extravagant. It’s a vehicle one can be proud to own and use frequently without hesitation. Parts are reasonably priced, and maintenance can be performed at most auto repair shops, enhancing its practicality.
Scott looking impressed in a 2023 cadillac xt5
Despite minor shortcomings, the 2023 XT5 offers a significantly more enjoyable driving experience than basic economy cars. Ingress and egress are easy, even for those with mobility challenges. Visibility is excellent, and the rear cargo area is very spacious. It’s a well-rounded SUV suitable for a wide range of drivers.
The 2023 Cadillac XT5 tends to attract attention, particularly from an older demographic, which can be a conversation starter at parking lots and public places.
Pros and Cons
While this review might highlight some criticisms, it’s important to acknowledge the overall merits of the 2023 Cadillac XT5. For those seeking a luxury SUV that doesn’t break the bank, the XT5 is a compelling option.
Pros
- Value for Money: Offers a near-luxury experience comparable to more expensive brands like Mercedes or Lexus, but at a more accessible price point.
- Highway Comfort: An exceptional highway cruiser, providing a comfortable and smooth ride, ideal for long distances.
- Attractive Styling: While not groundbreaking, the XT5’s design is stylish and appealing.
Cons
- Questionable Build Quality: Lacks the solid, meticulously engineered feel found in some competing luxury brands, particularly in terms of perceived material solidity.
- Poor Resale Value: Cadillac SUVs generally depreciate more quickly than some competitors, impacting long-term ownership costs.
- Underpowered Engine: The 2.0L four-cylinder engine, while adequate, doesn’t deliver the performance expected in a luxury SUV, especially at higher price trims.
Conclusion
The 2023 Cadillac XT5 strikes a balance between luxury and practicality. It’s a comfortable, spacious, and stylish midsize SUV that offers a premium experience without the premium price tag of some European rivals. While the engine performance and build quality might not be class-leading, the XT5 compensates with its comfortable interior, smooth ride, and overall value proposition, making it a worthy consideration for those seeking a cost-effective entry into the luxury SUV market.
