When it comes to the realm of compact luxury sports sedans, the market is brimming with contenders vying for the top spot. While the 2024 Audi S4 might not be crowned as the absolute best, or even the most potent Audi offering (with enthusiasts still yearning for the elusive RS4 Avant), it occupies a unique and compelling niche. This Audi S4 Review dives deep into why this model stands out by expertly blending daily drivability with spirited performance, making it a truly versatile and appealing choice for discerning drivers. It’s a car that whispers its capabilities rather than shouting them, embodying the essence of a true sleeper.
The Audi S4 Prestige, the trim level we evaluated, represents the pinnacle of the B9 generation S4, a model that has been refined since its initial launch in 2016 and further updated in 2020. While anticipation builds for its successor, the current S4 maintains its core appeal, largely thanks to its robust 3.0-liter turbocharged V6 engine. This powerplant consistently delivers 349 horsepower and 369 lb-ft of torque, channeled to all four wheels via Audi’s signature quattro all-wheel drive system and a smooth-shifting eight-speed ZF automatic transmission. Our test model further benefited from the optional Sport differential, enhancing agility by actively distributing torque across the rear axle, effectively mitigating understeer during spirited driving.
Audi S4 Front View on Road
Driving Dynamics: Balancing Comfort and Performance
The true essence of the Audi S4 lies in its remarkable versatility on the road. It’s equally at home navigating the mundane daily commute as it is carving through winding backroads. For those long stretches on the highway, the S4 provides a comfortable and composed ride, isolating occupants from road imperfections and noise. Yet, when the opportunity arises to inject some excitement into the drive, the S4 readily transforms. Opting for the adaptive dampers, a crucial component of the S Sport Package, elevates the driving experience significantly, allowing the car to dynamically adjust to varying road conditions and driving styles without compromising ride quality.
Our test vehicle was also equipped with the Dynamic Steering system, an optional feature that adjusts the steering ratio based on speed and driving situation. This technology aims to provide lighter, more direct steering at lower speeds for easier maneuverability, and heavier, more stable steering at higher speeds. While opinions on such systems can be divided, the Dynamic Steering in the S4 proved to be a welcome addition. Even in its most responsive setting, the steering retained a communicative feel, offering a satisfying blend of minimal effort and maximal feedback.
Audi S4 Interior with Red Stitching
Considering the S4’s positioning below the high-performance RS4, the available power and grip are more than adequate for most drivers. Audi claims a 0-60 mph acceleration time of 4.4 seconds, a figure that feels entirely believable from behind the wheel. The eight-speed automatic transmission is a seamless partner to the V6 engine, delivering smooth and responsive shifts. During our time with the S4, there was little need to engage the paddle shifters, as the transmission’s shift logic intelligently adapted to driving inputs and selected the appropriate gear. The selectable driving modes further allow drivers to tailor the powertrain’s responsiveness to their preferences, adjusting both throttle sensitivity and transmission behavior.
While the S4’s driving experience is largely positive, there are a couple of minor critiques. The turbocharged V6 engine emits a somewhat muted, high-pitched drone that may not appeal to all enthusiasts seeking a more visceral engine note. Additionally, the brake pedal exhibits a slightly overly sensitive initial bite, requiring a period of adjustment for smooth modulation. However, these are minor quibbles that do little to detract from the overall driving enjoyment.
Audi S4 Gear Stick and Central Console
Interior Refinement and Technology
Stepping inside the Audi S4 is a breath of fresh air in a world of increasingly complex and button-less interiors. The cabin strikes a harmonious balance between modern design and user-friendliness, retaining physical buttons for essential functions, a welcome departure from overly digitized interfaces. The interior of our test car was enhanced by the Audi Sport appearance package, which introduces striking red stitching on the seats and steering wheel, along with sophisticated carbon fiber trim across the dashboard. Notably, the carbon fiber trim in the S4 is particularly well-executed, catching light in a subtle yet visually appealing manner.
Visibility from the driver’s seat is excellent, with slim A-pillars contributing to a panoramic view of the road ahead. The well-considered driving position further enhances the feeling of agility, making the S4 feel more compact and maneuverable than its actual dimensions might suggest, particularly beneficial in tight urban environments. In an era where many modern cars can feel somewhat claustrophobic, the S4’s airy cabin is a testament to thoughtful design.
Audi S4 Front Seats and Dashboard
All S4 models come standard with massaging front seats, a feature that initially sparked excitement but ultimately proved to be somewhat underwhelming. While there is indeed movement within the seatbacks, the massage function lacks the intensity and deliberate action to provide genuine relief or relaxation. However, the seats themselves are inherently comfortable and supportive, even without the massage feature.
The Audi MMI infotainment system, while functional, falls short of class-leading in terms of intuitiveness. Navigating through menus can be cumbersome, with certain settings buried deep within layers of options. Furthermore, the wireless Apple CarPlay integration in our test car exhibited frustrating connectivity issues, intermittently disconnecting and reconnecting, a problem not unique to Audi but nonetheless disruptive.
Audi S4 Rear Seats and Legroom
Trims, Options, and Pricing: Finding the Right S4 for You
The 2024 Audi S4 lineup starts at a base price of $55,595, including destination charges. Stepping up to the Premium Plus trim at $58,595 and the top-tier Prestige at $62,895 primarily unlocks additional interior amenities and technology. The Premium Plus trim adds notable features such as Audi’s Virtual Cockpit digital instrument cluster, a 360-degree camera system, an upgraded Bang & Olufsen sound system, wireless phone charging, and advanced driver-assistance systems like Audi Pre Sense rear.
The Prestige trim, as tested, further elevates the S4 with matrix LED headlights, a head-up display, integrated navigation, heated rear seats, and enhanced ambient lighting. While these features add to the luxury experience, the truly transformative upgrades for driving enthusiasts lie in the optional S Sport Package. This package, encompassing adaptive dampers, the Sport rear differential, and red brake calipers, represents a worthwhile investment for those prioritizing dynamic performance.
Audi S4 Matrix LED Headlights
Our test vehicle, loaded with options including the Black Optic exterior trim, Audi Sport interior package, and Dynamic Steering, reached a total price of $69,340, positioning it at the higher end of the S4 spectrum. However, for those seeking the sweet spot of performance and value, a more modestly equipped S4, focusing on the essential performance-enhancing options like the adaptive dampers and Sport differential, presents a compelling proposition. A well-configured S4, balancing necessary performance features with a focus on value, can be had for around $58,000.
Audi S4 Black Optic Wheels
Competitive Landscape: S4 vs. Rivals
At this price point, the Audi S4 enters a fiercely competitive segment, squaring off against formidable rivals such as the Mercedes-AMG C43, BMW M340i, Lexus IS 500, and Cadillac CT4-V. Each of these competitors brings a unique character and powertrain to the table. The Mercedes-AMG C43 boasts cutting-edge technology with its Formula 1-derived turbocharger on a four-cylinder engine. The BMW M340i is renowned for its driver-focused dynamics and inline-six engine. The Lexus IS 500 appeals with its naturally aspirated V8, while the Cadillac CT4-V offers a blend of performance and value, with the Blackwing variant even offering a manual transmission.
In this landscape, the Audi S4 carves out its niche as the understated all-rounder. It may not possess the outright technological prowess of the C43, the laser-focused driving dynamics of the M340i, or the V8 charm of the IS 500. Instead, the S4 offers a balanced and accessible blend of luxury, performance, and everyday usability, making it a compelling value proposition within the segment. It’s the sensible yet satisfying choice for those who appreciate understated competence and a well-rounded driving experience.
Fuel Efficiency: Surprisingly Economical
The Audi S4 achieves EPA fuel economy ratings of 21 mpg city and 29 mpg highway, figures that prove to be somewhat conservative in real-world driving. During highway driving in comfort mode, we observed fuel economy reaching as high as 31 mpg, demonstrating the S4’s ability to be surprisingly efficient when driven with economy in mind. This efficiency is a valuable attribute for a car designed to be a versatile daily driver.
Audi S4 Fuel Economy Chart
Compared to its competitors, the S4’s fuel economy is competitive within the segment, further enhancing its appeal as a practical yet sporty luxury sedan.
Verdict: The Quintessential Sleeper Sedan
In conclusion, the 2024 Audi S4 emerges as a highly desirable luxury sports sedan, characterized by its understated elegance and well-rounded capabilities. While its exterior styling may not command attention, beneath the surface lies a car that excels in delivering a refined and engaging driving experience. Its strengths lie in its comfortable yet sporty nature, versatile performance, and compelling value proposition compared to many of its rivals.
For those prioritizing a balance of performance and everyday usability in a luxury sedan, the Audi S4 stands out as an intelligent choice. It’s a car that rewards discerning drivers with its understated competence and delivers on all fronts without unnecessary drama. If you seek a luxury sports sedan that blends into the background yet provides a genuinely rewarding driving experience, the Audi S4 deserves serious consideration – just perhaps opt for a more vibrant exterior color to truly appreciate its subtle sporting character.
| 2024 Audi S4 Specs |
|---|
| Base Price (Prestige as tested) |
| Powertrain |
| Horsepower |
| Torque |
| Seating Capacity |
| Curb Weight |
| Cargo Volume |
| 0-60 mph |
| Top Speed |
| EPA Fuel Economy |
| Quick Take |
| Score |
Audi S4 Rear View on Road
