The luxury electric vehicle market is rapidly expanding, offering discerning drivers a blend of opulence, performance, and sustainability. Among the frontrunners in this competitive segment are the BMW iX and the Porsche Taycan. Both vehicles represent the pinnacle of electric engineering from two of Germany’s most prestigious automakers, but they cater to slightly different tastes and priorities. Let’s delve into what makes each of these models stand out as contenders for the title of the Best Luxury Electric Car.
BMW iX: The Luxurious Electric SUV with Unmatched Refinement
The BMW iX marks a bold step into the electric future for BMW, embodying a blend of SUV versatility and groundbreaking electric technology. As described by Autocar, it’s “a BMW like no other,” aiming to redefine the brand’s identity in the EV era.
Pros:
- Exceptional Ride Comfort and Refinement: The iX truly shines in its ability to deliver a supremely comfortable and quiet ride. Its “isolation and sophistication” are highlighted as “very special indeed,” surpassing even competitors like the Mercedes-Benz EQS in ride quality. This makes the iX an ideal choice for those prioritizing a relaxing and serene driving experience.
- Spacious and Versatile SUV Design: Offering the practicality of an SUV with ample passenger and cargo space, the iX is perfect for families or individuals needing versatility. Its size is comparable to the BMW X5, ensuring it meets the demands of daily life with ease.
- Luxurious and Inviting Interior: Stepping inside the iX reveals a cabin that is both futuristic and warmly inviting. It distinguishes itself from the “wide-eyed futurism” of some rivals by offering a more “idiosyncratic and less formal flavour,” creating a unique and pleasant environment for both driver and passengers.
Cons:
- Polarizing Exterior Design: The iX’s exterior styling is undeniably divisive. It represents a significant departure from traditional BMW design cues, and while some appreciate its avant-garde approach, others may find it less appealing.
- Regenerative Braking Could Be Finer: While effective, the regenerative braking system in the iX is noted as an area for potential improvement. Some drivers might desire a more seamless and adjustable braking feel.
- Premium Price Point: As a flagship luxury electric SUV, the BMW iX comes with a significant price tag. Starting at around £70,000 for the entry-level xDrive40 and climbing to £92,000 for the xDrive50, it represents a substantial investment.
Despite these minor drawbacks, the BMW iX excels in delivering a comprehensive luxury EV package. Its combination of SUV practicality, exceptional comfort, and refined driving dynamics makes it a strong contender for the best luxury electric car in the SUV category.
Porsche Taycan: The Electric Sports Saloon with Thrilling Dynamics
The Porsche Taycan burst onto the scene in 2020 and quickly established itself as a benchmark for electric performance and handling. Porsche has since expanded the Taycan range to include various body styles and performance levels, broadening its appeal within the luxury electric segment.
Pros:
- Outstanding Handling and Driving Dynamics: The Taycan is celebrated for its “outstanding handling” and “fine handling response.” It delivers a driving experience that is unmistakably Porsche, even in electric form. Its ability to blend sporty dynamics with electric efficiency is a key differentiator.
- Sophisticated and Comfortable Ride: Beyond its sporty nature, the Taycan also offers a “sophisticated ride.” It manages to strike a balance between engaging handling and comfortable cruising, making it suitable for both spirited drives and everyday use.
- Improved Electric Range: Porsche has continuously refined the Taycan, and the 2024 models boast improved electric ranges. With a real-world range of around 250 miles in mixed conditions, the Taycan addresses a common concern among EV buyers.
Cons:
- Less Spacious Interior Compared to Saloons: While practical for its class, the Taycan isn’t as spacious as some traditional full-size saloons. Ingress and egress are also noted as being “a bit tight,” which might be a consideration for some buyers.
- Not the Most Practical for Cargo: Although the Taycan offers a usable boot, its cargo capacity is not as generous as some competitors or SUV alternatives. Buyers needing maximum luggage space might find it slightly limiting.
- Depreciation Concerns: The review mentions that “residual values aren’t what they used to be,” which could be a factor for buyers concerned about long-term ownership costs and resale value.
However, the Porsche Taycan’s strengths lie in its unparalleled driving experience and brand prestige. It represents the best luxury electric car for those who prioritize performance, handling, and the thrill of driving, all within a sophisticated and increasingly practical electric package.
Conclusion:
Choosing between the BMW iX and Porsche Taycan as the “best luxury electric car” ultimately depends on individual priorities. The BMW iX excels as a luxurious, comfortable, and versatile electric SUV, ideal for those seeking refinement and practicality. The Porsche Taycan, on the other hand, stands out as a dynamic and engaging electric sports saloon, perfect for drivers who crave performance and a thrilling driving experience. Both vehicles represent the pinnacle of electric luxury and offer compelling choices within their respective segments.
