When discussing iconic American automobiles, the Ford Mustang, with its legendary pony emblem, invariably comes to mind. For over half a century, the Mustang has been the quintessential accessible muscle car, delivering thrilling performance to generations of car enthusiasts. While many competitors have come and gone, the Ford Mustang has steadfastly remained a cornerstone of the sports car market.
However, the Mustang, like many sports cars, isn’t particularly known for its stellar reliability. This is a crucial consideration for anyone considering a used model. Therefore, understanding which model years offer the best reliability is essential for making a smart purchase.
In this guide, we’ll explore recent generations of this iconic muscle car to pinpoint the most reliable Ford Mustang years and identify models you might want to avoid.
5th Generation Ford Mustang (2005-2014)
Unless you are specifically seeking a vintage Mustang, focusing on the fifth generation for a used purchase is a wise move. The 2005 model year marked a significant redesign, celebrated for its advancements in comfort, styling, and performance.
Recommended Buy: 2005 Ford Mustang
Debut models of new vehicle generations often face initial reliability hiccups. Remarkably, the 2005 Ford Mustang bucked this trend, though it wasn’t without some issues.
CarComplaints.com data indicates over 1,000 complaints and nine recalls for the 2005 Mustang. The primary concern reported is the transmission system. Around the 60,000-mile mark, transmission failure was reported, often preceded by gear slippage. Additionally, over 20 complaints detail paint oxidation and rust, especially under the hood paint, affecting the vehicle’s appearance.
Despite these issues, the 2005 Mustang remains a relatively reliable sports car option in the used market.
Years to Avoid: 2006 Ford Mustang
The 2006 model year is less desirable. The NHTSA has recorded 560 complaints for the 2006 Mustang, with a significant portion related to the widespread Takata airbag recalls. The 2006 model also carried over the paint oxidation and rusting issues from the previous year, detracting from the Mustang’s aesthetics. It’s advisable to bypass the 2006 Ford Mustang to avoid potential headaches.
Top Pick: 2008 Ford Mustang
The 2008 year stands out as a highlight within the fifth-generation Mustang lineup and can be considered one of the Best Mustang Years for reliability. Consumer Reports awarded the 2008 Mustang a perfect reliability score of 5.0 out of 5.0. This score encompassed major vehicle systems including the engine, drive system, electrical components, and brakes.
However, the bubbling paint issue persisted, so a pre-purchase inspection should include checking for this cosmetic problem.
Years to Avoid: 2010-2012 Ford Mustang
While not severely unreliable overall, the 2010-2012 Ford Mustang models are notably prone to body and paint problems. The 2010 Ford Mustang, for instance, received 27 complaints specifically about hood corrosion. Owners reported paint bubbling on the hood even with low mileage and careful maintenance, suggesting a potential Ford manufacturing defect across several models and years.
If avoiding paint issues is a priority, these three model years are best skipped.
Recommended Buy: 2014 Ford Mustang
The 2014 Ford Mustang is highly coveted as the final model of the S197 Mustang generation. It’s a strong sports car with powerful V6 and V8 engine options and extensive customization possibilities. Crucially, its reliability record is excellent. Consumer Reports gave the 2014 Ford Mustang another top reliability score of 5.0 out of 5.0. While some reports of bubbling paint exist, it is less frequently reported in this model year.
6th Generation Ford Mustang (2015-2023)
The sixth generation Mustang brought a stylish redesign and introduced a turbocharged four-cylinder engine option. Reliability is generally strong in this generation, though some specific years should be approached with caution.
Years to Avoid: 2015-2016 Ford Mustang
The 2015 and 2016 Mustangs aren’t inherently unreliable, and they boast strong engine performance. However, they experienced a range of issues that might deter some buyers.
The 2015 Mustang also faced numerous complaints about peeling paint, often occurring around 30,000 miles, particularly on surfaces exposed to sunlight. Additionally, Mustangs equipped with the EcoBoost engine sometimes suffered from shaking and stalling, commonly resolved by replacing the PCV valve.
Top Picks: 2018-2019 Ford Mustang
The 2018 and 2019 Ford Mustangs are excellent choices from both a performance and value perspective. Benefiting from an independent rear suspension, they offer superior handling and road manners for high-performance vehicles. Ford also significantly improved the reliability of these models.
CarComplaints data shows the 2018 Mustang with just over 130 complaints and three recalls. The 2019 Ford Mustang shows even fewer complaints, also with three recalls. The issues reported for these years are mainly electrical and technology-related, crucially avoiding the pervasive bubbling paint issue of earlier models.
Consumer Reports rated both the 2018 and 2019 models with a perfect 5.0 out of 5.0 Reliability Verdict and a 4.0 out of 5.0 Owner Satisfaction score, highlighting their reliability as better than average for sports cars. While the 2018 Mustang had slightly lower scores in transmission and suspension, the 2019 model improved in these areas.
FAQs: Most Reliable Ford Mustang Years
Q: Which Ford Mustang model years are recognized for their reliability?
A: For used Ford Mustang buyers seeking reliability, the 2005, 2008, and 2014 models from the fifth generation, and the 2018 and 2019 models from the sixth generation stand out as exceptionally reliable choices. These years are consistently praised for their performance, style, and fewer reported problems.
Q: Why is the 2006 Ford Mustang considered a year to avoid?
A: The 2006 model year had a notable increase in complaints, primarily concerning the extensive Takata airbag recalls and ongoing paint oxidation issues, especially around the hood. These problems, particularly the cosmetic paint issues, can negatively impact the ownership experience.
Q: Are there specific years between 2010 and 2012 Ford Mustangs that should be avoided?
A: Yes, the 2010 through 2012 Mustang models are known for body and paint issues, with the 2010 model receiving numerous complaints about corrosion on the hood. While still offering the Mustang driving experience, these years come with a higher risk of cosmetic and rust-related problems.
Q: What makes the 2014 Ford Mustang a recommended model?
A: The 2014 model, as the final year of the S197 generation, is highly desirable due to its powerful engine options, customization options, and strong reliability track record. Consumer Reports awarded it a top reliability score, making it a highly recommended used Mustang despite some minor lingering paint bubbling concerns.
Find the Best Used Cars Near You
The CoPilot car shopping app simplifies the car buying process. Just tell us what you’re looking for, and we’ll search dealership inventories in your area to create a personalized list of top car listings.
CoPilot utilizes the same technology dealerships use for inventory trading, providing you with more comprehensive vehicle information than other platforms. We don’t partner with dealerships, ensuring unbiased results — just detailed information on the best cars available. Visit our About Us page to learn more about how CoPilot can assist you in finding your next car.
