The BMW X1 stands out in the compact SUV segment by prioritizing driving engagement and offering a range of potent engines. This review delves into the performance aspects of the X1, examining its engine options, acceleration capabilities, ride comfort, and overall driving experience compared to its competitors.
Engine Line-up and Performance Specs
The BMW X1 boasts a diverse engine range, starting with the sDrive20i petrol variant. This model delivers 168bhp, achieving a 0-62mph acceleration in a respectable 8.3 seconds, slightly outpacing the Volvo XC40 B3. For those seeking more spirited performance, the xDrive23i variant increases output to 215bhp, reducing the 0-62mph sprint to a more brisk 7.1 seconds. At the top of the petrol range sits the M35i xDrive, a performance-focused model that completes the 0-62mph dash in just 5.4 seconds, offering genuinely hot-hatch levels of pace in an SUV body.
BMW also caters to the plug-in hybrid market with two PHEV options: the xDrive25e and the xDrive30e. These models offer impressive electric ranges of up to 53 miles, surpassing PHEV versions of rivals such as the Range Rover Evoque and Volvo XC40. The xDrive25e achieves 0-62mph in 6.8 seconds, while the more powerful xDrive30e shaves that down to 5.7 seconds, blending electric efficiency with satisfying performance.
For diesel enthusiasts, the X1 presents two engine choices. The sDrive18d, with 148bhp, manages 0-62mph in 8.9 seconds, providing adequate performance comparable to the entry-level diesel Range Rover Evoque. The xDrive23d offers enhanced performance, reducing the sprint time by approximately a second, a difference that is noticeable in everyday driving.
Acceleration and Speed: 0-60 mph Analysis
Across the range, the BMW X1 demonstrates commendable acceleration figures. The petrol engines, particularly the xDrive23i and M35i xDrive, offer genuinely rapid performance for the segment. The PHEV models also deliver strong acceleration, especially in electric mode, providing instant torque and a responsive feel. Even the base sDrive20i petrol and sDrive18d diesel offer sufficient pace for most drivers, ensuring the X1 never feels underpowered in typical driving scenarios.
Gearbox and Drive Systems
The BMW X1 is available with front-wheel drive (sDrive models) or four-wheel drive (xDrive models), depending on the engine chosen. The standard gearbox is well-matched to each engine, providing smooth and responsive shifts. The xDrive system in four-wheel-drive models enhances traction and stability, particularly in adverse weather conditions or on less-than-perfect road surfaces.
Suspension and Ride Comfort
The BMW X1 offers two suspension setups: the standard system and the optional M Adaptive suspension. While we have primarily tested the adaptive version, it’s apparent that even in its Comfort setting, the ride can be firmer than some competitors. Road imperfections can be noticeable, and the ride can feel somewhat unsettled on poorer surfaces. At higher speeds, the ride smooths out, but it doesn’t quite reach the levels of plushness and sophistication found in rivals like the Genesis GV70, Range Rover Evoque, or Volvo XC40.
Handling and Driving Dynamics
Despite the firm ride, the BMW X1 excels in handling. It offers a more engaging driving experience than many of its rivals, with precise steering and well-controlled body roll in corners. The steering, while perhaps a touch light at higher speeds for some drivers seeking maximum feedback, is generally accurate and responsive, contributing to the X1’s agile feel. Overall, the X1 provides a more driver-focused experience than many compact SUVs, aligning with BMW’s reputation for sporty handling.
Noise and Refinement
While engine performance is a strong point, engine refinement in the BMW X1 is an area where it lags slightly behind some competitors. The engines, particularly the petrol units when pushed, can be a little noisier than those in rivals. While not excessively intrusive, drivers seeking ultimate quietness and refinement might find competitors like the Volvo XC40 to offer a more hushed driving experience.
Strengths and Weaknesses (Summarized)
Strengths:
- Strong and varied engine options, including potent petrols and efficient PHEVs.
- Competitive electric range in PHEV models.
- Engaging handling and driving dynamics.
Weaknesses:
- Firmer ride compared to some rivals.
- Engines can be noisier than competitors, especially under load.
- Steering feel could be more substantial at higher speeds.
BMW X1 vs. Rivals (Brief Comparison)
Compared to rivals like the Volvo XC40, Range Rover Evoque, and Genesis GV70, the BMW X1 prioritizes driving engagement and offers a wider range of powerful engines. However, it compromises slightly on ride comfort and engine refinement in the pursuit of a sportier driving experience. The choice between the X1 and its competitors will ultimately depend on individual priorities, with the X1 appealing most to those who value performance and handling in a compact SUV.
