When considering a high-performance SUV, the choices within the BMW X5 lineup often come down to the formidable X5M and the potent X5 M60i. For those with the luxury of choosing between these two without financial constraints, the decision hinges on a deeper understanding of what each model offers. With the 2024 pricing details now available, it’s time to dissect the options, features, and crucially, the horsepower advantage of the BMW X5M.
Initial assumptions might lean towards the X5M as the default choice for performance enthusiasts. However, a detailed comparison reveals a more nuanced picture. Let’s delve into the specifics to understand the strengths and trade-offs of each model.
Interestingly, the X5 M60i boasts several features not available on its more powerful sibling, the X5M. These include practical additions like:
- 3AC Trailer Hitch: Enhancing versatility for towing or accessory attachments.
- 5AX Highway Assistant (in the ZDY package): Advanced driver assistance for enhanced highway driving.
- 2VR 2-axle air suspension: Providing a more comfortable and adaptable ride quality.
- 2VH Integral Active Steering (4-wheel steering): Improving maneuverability and agility.
Conversely, the BMW X5M offers a unique set of premium features absent in the X5 M60i, focusing on luxury and performance aesthetics:
- 44A Heated and Cooled cup holders: A touch of luxury for everyday convenience.
- 453 Front Ventilated Seats: Essential for comfort in warmer climates.
- X3DA Sakhir Orange/Black Full Merino Leather: Exclusive, high-end interior upholstery option.
- C4G Isle of Man Green metallic: A distinctive and sporty exterior color choice.
- 3M5/3M6 M Compound brakes with either red or black calipers: Performance braking with visual flair.
- 4MA Multi-function seats with lumbar support: Enhanced seating adjustability and support for driver and passenger.
- 4GQ M Seat belts: Sporty design detail reflecting the M pedigree.
- Full Merino leather seats: Premium leather upholstery throughout the cabin.
Of course, the heart of the matter lies in performance. The X5M stands as a true M car, embodying the full suite of performance engineering and aesthetic enhancements that define the M badge. A significant differentiator is the Bmw X5m Hp, delivering a commanding 617 horsepower, compared to the still impressive 523 horsepower of the X5 M60i. Despite this horsepower advantage, both models share the same torque figure of 553 lb-ft, indicating robust pulling power across the rev range.
This enhanced performance of the X5M comes at a premium, both in initial cost and running expenses, particularly in fuel consumption. However, for buyers in this segment, fuel efficiency is likely a secondary concern to the thrill of driving a high-performance machine.
Let’s examine the financial aspect with both models configured with virtually all available options, based on 2024 pricing guides. A fully loaded BMW X5M reaches an MSRP of $137,625, including destination fees. The similarly equipped X5 M60i totals $115,025, also inclusive of destination fees.
Considering additional real-world costs such as a dealer fee of $999, a trade-in value of $21,227 (using a 2016 X5 50i as a reference), and a 6% sales tax plus a local option sales tax of $25, the total expenditure becomes $124,412.82 for the X5M and $100,456.82 for the X5 M60i. This reveals a price difference of approximately $23,956.
The absence of features like Highway Assistant, air suspension, and active steering on the X5M is notable, especially considering its performance focus. The desire for a trailer hitch option on the X5M, primarily for accessory carriers like bike racks rather than heavy towing, is also a valid point for some buyers. Active steering, in particular, seems like a feature that would complement the X5M’s dynamic character and arguably should be a standard inclusion.
While the X5 M60i lacks some of the X5M’s exclusive luxury features like heated and cooled cup holders and ventilated seats, these are not necessarily deal-breakers for everyone. However, the allure of full Merino leather seats in the X5M is undeniable, offering a significant upgrade in cabin ambiance and tactile quality.
Ultimately, the choice between the BMW X5M and X5 M60i is a matter of priorities. Do you prioritize ultimate horsepower and exclusive M features, accepting a higher price and slightly reduced versatility in some areas? Or does the X5 M60i’s blend of strong performance, added features like air suspension and highway assistant, and a more accessible price point make it the more compelling option? Considering all factors, which model would you choose and what drives your decision?
