Deciding between the Mazda Miata MX-5 and the Subaru BRZ often comes down to more than just comparing horsepower or handling. For many enthusiasts considering a fun, sporty car, the choice reflects different needs and priorities in daily life. Both are excellent vehicles, but cater to slightly different drivers and lifestyles.
One key factor is size. If you’re a shorter driver looking for a nimble car ideally suited for motorsports, the MX-5 Miata stands out. Its compact dimensions and lightweight design make it exceptionally agile, especially on track. Adding a roll bar enhances its safety for more demanding driving environments.
However, for those needing more practicality, particularly if the sports car is also your daily driver, the BRZ presents a more logical option. It offers greater cargo space and a cabin that accommodates taller individuals more comfortably. If you’re over six feet tall and need to transport items – whether it’s gear for autocross or luggage for a weekend trip – the BRZ’s added room becomes a significant advantage.
From an engineering perspective, the ND2 generation Miata engine is renowned for its robust design and durability. Many consider it to be over-engineered, capable of withstanding considerable stress and offering reliable performance. The Miata also boasts superior suspension geometry and benefits from strong factory support from Mazda Motorsports, making it a compelling choice for serious enthusiasts. Furthermore, the Miata’s lighter weight contributes to superior fuel economy, often achieving significantly better mileage than the BRZ.
Despite the MX-5’s numerous strengths, the BRZ remains a strong contender, especially if the Miata’s size is a limiting factor. For drivers who find the Miata too small or cannot install a roll bar, the BRZ offers a next-best alternative. It strikes a unique balance, being both more hardcore in some respects (potentially in terms of aftermarket customization and track focus for some) and less hardcore in others (more daily drivable and practical).
Ultimately, both the MX-5 Miata and the BRZ are rewarding sports cars. The ideal choice depends on individual needs, size, and how the car will fit into your broader lifestyle. Owning both would be a dream for many enthusiasts, highlighting their distinct appeals and complementary strengths in the sports car world.
