The Tesla Model 3 revolutionized the electric vehicle market upon its debut in 2017, but the spotlight soon shifted to the Tesla Model Y. By early 2024, the Model Y ascended to become the world’s best-selling car, across all categories. For those considering joining the Tesla family or upgrading their current EV, the choice between the Model 3 and Model Y can be crucial. This comparison delves into the key differences and similarities between these two popular models to help you determine which Tesla best suits your needs.
From Model 3 to Model Y: A Personal Upgrade Story
One Tesla owner, Andrew Leonard from Recurrent, experienced this decision firsthand. Initially a Model 3 owner since early 2022, an unexpected accident led him to explore the Model Y. While satisfied with his Model 3, a collision with a driver running a red light resulted in his vehicle being totaled. Fortunately, safety features and robust construction ensured everyone involved was unharmed.
Rear collision between two cars
Faced with replacing his car, Andrew considered the Model Y. Interestingly, the Model Y had been his initial Tesla preference. However, during his first purchase consideration, the Model Y was newly in production, and he was not fully convinced by the initial build quality during a test drive. This led him to choose the well-established Model 3 instead. This time around, things were different.
Space and Practicality: The Model Y’s Winning Card
The Model Y proved to be a significant upgrade, primarily due to its enhanced cargo space and overall practicality. Although only marginally larger than the Model 3 in overall length (approximately two inches), the Model Y boasts an extra 1.6 inches in width and sits 1.3 inches higher. These seemingly small dimensional increases translate into a considerably more spacious interior. Passengers in the Model Y enjoy about an inch more headroom and a notable five inches of additional legroom in the rear seats.
However, the most substantial difference lies in cargo capacity. The five-seat Model Y offers a voluminous 34.3 cubic feet of cargo space compared to the Model 3’s 22.9 cubic feet. This expanded space transforms the Model Y into a truly utilitarian vehicle. For Andrew, this meant easily accommodating a collapsed e-bike and a full-size road bike in the rear, even with additional room for luggage in the under-floor compartments and the front trunk (frunk).
A packed trunk, complete with dog
Ride Comfort and Driving Position: Model Y Prioritizes Comfort
Beyond space, ride height and seating comfort were key improvements for Andrew. He noted that the lower seating position in sedans had started causing back discomfort. Despite sharing the same seat design as the Model 3, the Model Y’s seats are mounted higher off the floor. This seemingly simple change to a more upright seating position significantly improved driving comfort. Andrew’s driving duration before experiencing back pain increased from about an hour in the Model 3 to three hours or more in the Model Y. While acknowledging a slightly different driving feel – more “on” the car rather than “in” it – the comfort gain was a worthwhile trade-off.
Performance and Technology: Similarities and Subtle Upgrades
In terms of technology and performance, the Model Y offers advancements. Andrew appreciated the upgraded Ryzen infotainment chip in the Model Y, which resulted in a noticeably more responsive touchscreen and navigation system. The transition from a Long Range Model 3 to a Model Y Performance also provided a noticeable boost in power. While the larger cabin of the Model Y does contribute to slightly increased road noise compared to the Model 3, it was not a significant concern.
Model Y vs. Model 3: Choosing the Right Tesla for You
Ultimately, the choice between the Tesla Model Y and Model 3 depends on individual needs and priorities. The Model 3 remains an excellent choice for those prioritizing sedan styling, potentially slightly better efficiency, and a more engaging, lower-to-the-ground driving feel. However, the Model Y distinguishes itself with superior practicality, significantly enhanced cargo space, and a more comfortable, upright seating position, making it exceptionally well-suited for families and individuals who value versatility and comfort. The features of the Model Y – space, ride height, and ease of use – are likely key factors in its rise to become a top-selling Tesla vehicle. Test driving both models is highly recommended to experience firsthand which Tesla aligns best with your lifestyle and preferences.
